Author Archives: George J.A. Murray

For Monday, 11 April

Prep

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. The Craft of Research: Know Your Sources!
  3. Q&A: TBA
  4. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time

  • Matt Miller, ‘Rap’s Dirty South: From Subculture to Pop Culture’, in Forman and Neal (2012).  keywords: commodification; Dirty South, the; imagined community; trap.

For Wednesday, 6 April

Prep

We’ll devote the entire class to group project work. More to come on how Forman’s chapter will fit into this.

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. Story Maps Workshop
  3. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time

  • Davarian Baldwin, ‘Black Empires, White Desires: The Spatial Politics of Identity in the Age of Hip-Hop’, in Forman and Neal (2012)

For Monday, 4 April

Prep

Yesterday we looked at a few examples of Paul Gilroy’s close readings of hip-hop tracks–Tim Dog’s ‘Fuck Compton’, the posse cut ‘H.E.A.L./Family Got to Get Busy’, and Ed O.G. and Da Bulldogs’ ‘Be a Father to Your Child’–as examples of how to use qualitative data in your Story Maps projects. That ended up taking the entire class period. So Monday we’ll dig in to the Rodman chapter on Eminem that we didn’t manage to get to on Wednesday. We also need to see where groups are at in terms of formulating a decent research question (some of you still haven’t even created your group Slack channels…).

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. Screening: ‘Rapping, deconstructed: The best rhymers of all time’, Vox (19 May 2016)
  3. Q&A: Eminem and the Cultural Politics of Authenticity
  4. Story Maps: Research Questions, Slack Channels
  5. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time

  • Murray Forman, ‘”Represent”: Race, Space, and Place in Rap Music’, in Forman and Neal (2012)

We’ll devote the entire class on Wednesday to group project work. More to come on how Forman’s chapter will fit into this.

For Monday, 28 March

Prep

  • Paul Gilroy, ‘It’s a Family Affair’, in Neal and Forman (2012). keywords: Afrocentrism; authenticity; black nationalism; diaspora; essentialism; hybridity.

We ended up using the whole period to review the Story Maps Proposal Outline assignment, so please review the Gilroy chapter for Monday and we’ll dive into that.

Take a close look at the lyrics that Gilroy cites as well as his reading of them: these readings will give us an opportunity to discuss the role of qualitative data in your Story Maps projects.

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. Q&A: TBA
  3. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time

For Wednesday, 16 March

Prep

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. Review: Story Maps Research Questions
  3. Review: Semester Goals HW
  4. Overview: Annotated Bibliography Assignment
  5. Q&A: TBA
  6. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time

  • Kembrew McLeod, ‘Authenticity Within Hip-Hop and Other Cultures Threatened With Assimilation’, in Forman and Neal (2012)

For Monday, 14 March

Prep

In Class: Formulate Your Research Question Exercise

  1. Use our class time to work on your group’s research question. You can do this on whatever platform you’re already using for communication within your group–WhatsApp, Dischord, Slack, Telegram, Facebook Messenger, Trump Social, whatever.
  2. Create a Slack Channel for your Story Maps group. Add me to this channel. This way, you always have a channel of communication to me as a group.
  3. On this channel, post the research question you all came up with as a group for your proposal outlines. Include at least a paragraph or two about the reasons for the group’s interest in the question, and address the following questions.
    • What is the geographical focus of your group’s study? Ideally, this will be neighbourhood-specific (e.g., the South Bronx; or Houston’s North Side; or Hollis, Queens), but it could also be a whole city, if that makes sense (e.g., Dar-Es-Salaam, Tanzania) or even a whole metropolitan region (e.g., the San Francisco Bay Area).
    • Who are the other members of your group?
    • Who was present for today’s discussion?
    • What is your group’s research question?
    • How does this research question meaningfully connect to at least one key concept, theme, or theory—a keyword, in short—from our reading or class discussions?
  4. In the ideal case, you will also have an idea of what your answer to the question–your thesis, in other words–might be. Thus, your discussion should make specific reference to the advice to be found in the Davis article. Below is a good example from a previous semester:

“How has extreme hypermasculinity and gender inequality entered Swissbeatbox’s Grand Beatbox Battle in Warsaw, Poland, despite not only the beatbox community’s values against oppression, but Poland’s significant level of gender equality between males and females?”

This question has been revised from the previous question “How has hypermasculinity and gender segregation entered the German and international beatbox community despite the communities fundamental values against oppression and the more feminist state of Eastern Germany.” through recent events of sexual assault and drugging that took place last month during this competition. After this event occurred, many beatboxers and community members came out with their experiences with sexual assault during not only the event but in other beatboxing events too. Our group has concluded that there is more room for research and credible sources as many beatboxers have spoken out in response to this event. Not only have hours of content on YouTube been published, but many survivors and community members have come out with their stories and spoken out about the issue on social media.

After reviewing the reading by Murray S. Davis, we believe that this research question can be deemed “interesting” as it reflects Davis’ fourth part of his “Index of the Interesting”, called “Generalization” [Davis 1971:317] Part A states “What seems to be a local phenomenon is in reality a general phenomenon” which will reflect our research because this issue is not exclusive to just the Grand Beatbox Battle in Poland but all around the beatbox community during in-person and online events.

For Next Time

  • Samy Alim, ‘“Bring It to the Cypher”: Hip-Hop Nation Language’, in Forman and Neal (2012)
  • Recommended: Adam Bradley, ‘The Artists Dismantling the Barriers Between Rap and Poetry’, New York Times (4 March 2021)
    • Audio: To complement T’s recent feature on how the barrier between rap and poetry is becoming increasingly porous thanks to a new generation of practitioners in both art forms, we asked a number of poets mentioned in the piece about the hip-hop songs they return to again and again.

 

REFERENCES

Davis, Murray S. 1971. ‘That’s Interesting! Towards a Phenomenology of Sociology and a Sociology of Phenomenology’. Philosophy of the Social Sciences 1(4):309-334. Retrieved 13 March 2022 (http://kieranhealy.org/files/misc/davis-thatsinteresting-1971.pdf).

For Wednesday, 9 March

Prep

In Class

  1. Attendance
  2. Overview: Semester Goals HW
  3. Classic Material (Slight Reprise): Story Map Research Questions
  4. Q&A: Hip-Hop Feminism
  5. Small Group Huddles
  6. Reading Notes for Next Time

For Next Time