DJs often think quite hard about what they’re going to play beforehand—but like Kool Herc, a good one will switch it up according to how the crowd is reacting in real time on the dancefloor. Think of this schedule of readings in the same light. Note also that I regularly make announcements in class, typically at the beginning of the period, about what’s coming next.
Week 1 – Introduction: Hip-Hop & the Academy
W 8/28
What do we gain from the academic study of hip-hop? And what do academics typically get wrong about hip-hop? (Note: These are all short texts or audiovisual clips; please make sure you check them out before our first meeting!)
- Ground Rules for the Classroom
- Frederick Douglas, ‘Learning to Read and Write’ (1845)
- Malcolm X, ‘Learning to Read’ (1965)
- Audio: GZA, ‘Swordsman’ (1995). keywords: autodidacticism; boom bap; cultural capital; Five Percenter rap; hip-hop studies; scholarship; symbolic capital.
- Video: Robert Glasper: “Jazz is the mother of hip-hop” | JAZZ NIGHT IN AMERICA (19 April 2017)
Week 2 – Taste, Culture, & Capital
M 9/2 NO CLASS (Labor Day)
W 9/4
How subjective can taste be for social animals like ourselves?
- Benedict Carey, ‘In Music, Others’ Tastes May Help Shape Your Own’, New York Times (14 February 2006)
- Shamus Khan, ‘The New Elitists’, New York Times (7 July 2012)
- Audio: ‘How to Listen to Music in 4 Easy Steps’, Switched on Pop 50
Week 3 – Hip-Hop History: Hip-Hop History: DJing and MCing
M 9/9
What’s the difference between rap and hip-hop music?
- Bill Brewster and Frank Broughton, ‘Hip-Hop Roots: Adventures on the Wheels of Steel’, in Last Night a DJ Saved My Life: The History of the Disc Jockey (Grove Press, 2006)
- Audio: Rich Nice, Merry Go Round Mix (11 August 2020)
- Video: Grandmaster Flash, ‘A Letter to Kool Herc from Grandmaster Flash’ (14 August 2017)
W 9/11
Is hip-hop inherently political?
- Bill Brewster and Frank Broughton, ‘Hip-Hop: Planet Rock’, in Last Night a DJ Saved My Life: The History of the Disc Jockey (Grove Press, 2006)
- Audio: Afrika Bambaataa, ‘Death Mix’ (1983), Parts 1 & 2
- Video: DJ Jazzy Jay | Crate Diggers | Fuse (10 October 2012). Jazzy Jay was one of Zulu Nation’s main DJs, was the co-founder of Def Jam Records, and is one of hip-hop’s great storytellers. keywords: crate digging; sacred crates.
Week 4 – Hip-Hop History: Dance & Visual Arts
M 9/16
How have various kinds of mass media influenced the evolution of hip-hop dance?
- Jorge ‘Popmaster Fabel’ Pabon, ‘Physical Graffiti: The History of Hip-Hop Dance’, in Jeff Chang, ed., Total Chaos: The Art and Aesthetics of Hip-Hop (BasicBooks, 2006). Also reprinted in Forman and Neal (2012).
- Audio: ‘Breaking’s Olympic Debut’, The Daily (9 August 2024)
- Video: Wild Style (Charlie Ahearn, 1982). We’ll watch this movie in class, but I encourage you to look at it a few times. You can view this movie for free using the hyperlink in the title.
W 9/18
Did street art survive its move to the galleries?
- Jeff Chang, ‘Zulus on a Time Bomb: Hip-Hop Meets the Rockers Downtown’, in Forman and Neal (2012). This time, we’ll focus on the sections having to do with graffiti.
- Norman Mailer, ‘The Faith of Graffiti’, Esquire (May 1974)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: Wild Style (Charlie Ahearn, 1982)
Week 5 – Hip-Hop Historiography
M 9/23
How do we separate history from mythology?
- Alex Gale, The Oral History of “Wild Style”, Complex (2013). Note: I advise watching the movie to the end before reading this.
- Video: Wild Style (Charlie Ahearn, 1982)
W 9/25
Did hip-hop really begin in the Bronx? (And if it did, was it a necessary consequence of social conditions and social forces? How much ‘nothing’ did this something come from?)
- Nelson George, ‘Hip-Hop’s Founding Fathers Speak the Truth’, in Forman and Neal (2012); also available in Forman and Neal (2004), pp. 45-56
- Video: Founding Fathers: The Untold Story of Hip-Hop (Ron Lawrence and Hassan Pore, 2009). Watch this before class; we’ll review a few scenes during class as they become relevant to our discussion.
Week 6 – Hip-Hop Historiography, cont’d
M 9/30
What defines a hip-hop classic?
- Andrew Nosnitsky, ‘Classic Material’, Pitchfork (19 November 2012)
- Audio: This should go without saying, but you need to listen to Nas’s Illmatic (1993) album if you don’t already know it. Even if you do know it, you should revisit it.
- Video: Kendrick Lamar: Good Kid, m.A.A.d. Classic (21 October 2017).
- Video: Marley Marl ‘Classic Recipes’ – Recreating MC Shan ‘The Bridge’ w/ Akai MPC Renaissance. Dubspot, 8 March 2013. Watch this video for some essential context to Queensbridge’s contributions to hip hop, as well as the technological and technical innovations that led to the classic sound we commonly refer to as ‘boom bap’.
W 10/2 NO CLASS
Week 7 – Writing and the Rhetoric of Rap: MCing
M 10/7
What can the study of linguistics teach us about the language of hip-hop?
- H. Samy Alim, ‘“Bring It to the Cypher”: Hip-Hop Nation Language’, in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: Chief Rocker Busy Bee Starski vs. Kool Moe Dee of The Treacherous Three (Harlem World, 1981)
- Video: The Art of Diss: The History of Battle Rap (2023)
W 10/9
What can the study of poetics teach us about rap lyricism?
- Adam Bradley, ‘Rhyme’, Ch. 2 in Book of Rhymes (2009)
- Audio: Adam Bradley, ‘American Poets on the Hip-Hop Songs That Most Inspire Them’, New York Times (4 March 2021). To complement T’s recent feature on how the barrier between rap and poetry is becoming increasingly porous thanks to a new generation of practitioners in both art forms, we asked a number of poets mentioned in the piece about the hip-hop songs they return to again and again. (These excerpts from interviews with various poets shouldn’t be read apart from the embedded Spotify playlist, ‘A Playlist from the Poets’.)
- Video: ‘Rapping, deconstructed: The best rhymers of all time’, Vox (19 May 2016)
Week 8 – Writing and the Rhetoric of Authenticity
M 10/14 NO CLASS
T 10/15 CLASSES FOLLOW A MONDAY SCHEDULE
How can we come up with a thesis, and what is the mark of a good one?
- Murray S. Davis, ‘That’s Interesting! Towards a Phenomenology of Sociology and a Sociology of Phenomenology’, Philosophy of the Social Sciences (1971)
- Audio: TBD
- Re-View: Robert Glasper: “Jazz is the mother of hip-hop” | JAZZ NIGHT IN AMERICA (19 April 2017). An example of a clearly stated, interesting thesis—and one that’s EXTREMELY debatable.
W 10/16
What do we mean when we talk about ‘authenticity’ in hip-hop?
- Kembrew McLeod, ‘Authenticity Within Hip-Hop and Other Cultures Threatened With Assimilation’ (password-protected PDF), in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: Adam Neely, ‘Why Are There So Few Cover Rap Songs?’ (22 September 2022)
Week 9 – Hip-Hop Politics: Conscious Rap
M 10/21
If hip-hop is ‘protest music’, why did so many conscious rappers support the patriarchy?
- Paul Gilroy, ‘It’s a Family Affair’ (password-protected PDF), in Neal and Forman (2012)
- Audio: ‘Allah B of the Nation of Gods and Earths’, The Cipher Show 151 (18 April 2016). Peace! We trace the history of the Nation of Gods and Earths – and its influence on hip-hop – with one of its earliest members.
- Video: An Overview of Afrocentricity with Dr Molefi Kete Asante, AfricentricTV (4 July 2021)
W 10/23
What do feminists hear when they listen to hip-hop?
- Tricia Rose, ‘Never Trust a Big Butt and a Smile’, in Forman and Neal (2004), pp. 291-306
- Audio: ‘Saweetie, City Girls, and the Female Rapper Renaissance’, Popcast (29 November 2020)
- Video: ‘Why Women Are Running Hip Hop Now’, Signified B Sides (26 February 2024)
Week 10 – Hip-Hop Politics: Conscious Rap, cont’d;
M 10/28
If hip-hop is protest music, why is there so much gaybashing?
- Mychal Denzel Smith, ‘Confessions of a Conscious Rap Fan’, Pitchfork (28 June 2022)
- Audio: ‘Kendrick Lamar’s Anxiety Era’, Popcast (24 May 2022)
- Video: ‘Do the Knowledge’, Hip-Hop Evolution S2E3 (2018)
W 10/30
Was gangsta rap the real conscious rap?
- Davarian Baldwin, ‘Black Empires, White Desires: The Spatial Politics of Identity in the Age of Hip-Hop’, (password-protected PDF) in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: ‘The REAL Faces of Black Conservatism’, F.D. Signifier (10 May 2023)
Week 11 – ‘Race’, Space, & Place
M 11/4
Where does keepin’ it real go wrong?
- Murray Forman, ‘Represent: Race, Space, and Place in Rap Music’, (password-protected PDF) in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: TBD
W 11/6
What exactly is ‘dirty’ about the ‘Dirty South’?
- Matt Miller, ‘Rap’s Dirty South: From Subculture to Pop Culture’, (password-protected PDF) in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: Tommy Wright III feat. La Chat and Playa Fly, ‘Gangsta Forever’ (1996). Justin Hunte mentions this track in ‘How the triplet flow took over rap’ as one of the first examples of the sustained use of double-time triplet flow. It also features an opening verse from the underappreciated La Chat, one of at least two great female MCs from that era of Memphis rap (the other is Gangsta Boo of Three Six Mafia). Note: The Boss DR-660, a very budget drum machine, was a staple of early Memphis rap production, particularly in the years 1993-1995; I’ll bring in the unit that I’ve been borrowing the last few weeks. The main sample for ‘Gangsta Forever’ is apparently taken from the Psycho II soundtrack, however, so that suggests that Wright had upgraded his equipment by then (the only samples available on the DR-660 were factory presets). Check out ‘Meet Yo Maker’ from his 1994 album Ashes 2 Ashes, Dust 2 Dust to hear him produce an entire beat on the DR-660. Since this drum machine did not feature a sampler, Memphis producers would take the stock 808 cowbell sound and pitch it at different frequencies to create melodies.
- Audio:
- Video: ‘How the triplet flow took over rap’, Vox (15 September 2017)
Week 12 – Sampling, Chopping, & Screwing
M 11/11
Is DJ Screw really to blame for Drake?
- Andrew Nosnitsky, ‘Gray Matters’, Pitchfork (4 March 2013). On the legacy of Houston’s DJ Screw—possibly the most influential hip-hop DJ of this century—and how his impact goes way beyond simply slowing things down.
- Video: ‘DJ Screw and Suc Freestyle’, ScrewdUPClickV2 (14 October 2009)
- Audio: ‘Big Floyd and the Rise of Houston Chopped N Screwed Music’, Switched on Pop (9 June 2020)
W 11/13
What’s creative about using other people’s records?
- Andrew Bartlett, ‘Airshafts, Loudspeakers, and the Hip-Hop Sample’. In Forman and Neal (2004; 2012)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: ‘How J Dilla Humanized His MPC3000’, Vox Earworm (6 December 2017)
Week 13 –
M 11/18
How much can we read into an artist’s sampling choices?
- Joseph Schloss, ‘Sampling Ethics’ (password-protected PDF), in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: ‘Kendrick Lamar and the big samples’ (2022)
- Video: TBD
W 11/20
Does the new wave of female MCs break any new ground when it comes to the gender politics that Tricia Rose wrote about back in the ’90s?
- Niela Orr, ‘The Future of Rap Is Female’, New York Times Magazine (9 August 2023)
- Audio: ‘Women’s Rap Renaissance’, Switched on Pop 198 (8 December 2020)
- Video: TBD
Week 14 – ‘Race’, Culture, & Appropriation
M 11/25
Is cultural appropriation always a bad thing?
- Gilbert B. Rodman, ‘Race … and Other Four-Letter Words: Eminem and the Cultural Politics of Authenticity’ (password-protected PDF), in Forman and Neal (2012)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: Adam Neely, ‘Scotch Snaps in Hip-Hop’ (11 March 2019)
W 11/27
Are rappers simply modern-day griots?
- William Jelani Cobb, ‘Asphalt Chronicles: Hip Hop and the Storytelling Tradition’, in Cobb, To the Break of Dawn: A Freestyle on the Hip Hop Aesthetic (NYU Press, 2007)
- Audio: Choose one song from among the ones discussed in the Ghostface ‘Brackets’ video below and listen to it carefully (it could be a song you’ve never heard before or one you’re already familiar with). How does it illustrate (or otherwise connect to) an idea in the assigned reading by William Jelani Cobb? Post a brief paragraph in our #discography channel on Discord the night before class and be as specific as possible (which, naturally, also entails citing ‘chapter and verse’ in the assigned reading).
- Video: ‘Ghostface Killah Crowns Best Storytelling Rap Song | Complex Brackets’, Complex (20 October 2021)
Week 15 – Sing About Me I: The Art of Storytelling
M 12/2
Has hip hop revolutionised the art of storytelling in any way? Is there a kind of storytelling that only a rap song can do? (And where have all the storytellers gone?)
- Adam Bradley, ‘Storytelling’, in Book of Rhymes (Basic Books, 2009)
- Henry Louis Gates, Jr., The Signifying Monkey (1988)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: TBD
W 12/4
Is storytelling overrated?
- Parul Sehgal, ‘The Tyranny of the Tale’, The New Yorker (10 & 17 July 2023)
- Audio: TBD
- Video: TBD
Week 16 – Sing About Me II: Politics of Storytelling
M 12/9
Even if hip hop gives ‘voice to the voiceless’, does that necessarily mean that anyone will listen to their stories?
- Francesca Polletta, Pang Ching Bobby Chen, Beth Gharrity Gardner, and Alice Motes, ‘The Sociology of Storytelling’, Annual Review of Sociology 37 (2011), pp. 109-130
- Audio: TBD
- Video: TBD
W 12/11 Last Day of Class
Can hip-hop storytelling help us to think?
- Isak Dinesen, ‘The Immortal Story’
- Hannah Arendt, ‘Isak Dinesen’ (in Men in Dark Times)
- Francesca Polletta, ‘Storytelling in Politics’, Contexts (2006)
- Audio: Kendrick Lamar, good kid, m.A.A.d. city (2012)
- Video: TBD
Final Exam Period — Oral Presentations for Extra Credit
TBA (note: 3:30pm-5:30pm)
- TBD
- Audio: TBD
- Video: TBD
*Final grades are due on the 27th of December. Please don’t ask me when I’ll have your grade, as I’ll almost certainly be working on Christmas Day and up until the last minute to make sure that everyone receives the grade they deserve.
REFERENCES
Forman, Murray, and Mark Anthony Neal. 2012. That’s the Joint! The Hip-Hop Studies Reader, 2nd Ed. New York: Routledge
Forman, Murray, and Mark Anthony Neal. 2004. That’s the Joint! The Hip-Hop Studies Reader, 1st Ed. New York: Routledge.